|
Fiction is obliged to stick to possibilities. Truth isn't. - Mark Twain
|
|
in Cattle to Birthplace ![]() Kristin Goff Fort Lewis College, April 2000 Abstract High
Altitude Pulmonary Edema (HAPE), is known in the cattle industry as
Brisket disease. Pulmonary arterial pressure (PAP) has been correlated
with the cause of HAPE. Evidence has shown that the breed of animal
plays a large role in the animal’s PAP score. One hundred twenty-four
yearling bulls of five different breeds came to Hesperus, Colorado to
participate in the 2000 Four Corners Bull Test, at an altitude of 7600
feet. The Four Corners Bull Test Station has been testing bulls for
breeding soundness, average daily gain, and their PAP since 1949. This
study explores the relationship between PAP and altitude. This
experiment found that there is little correlation between where the
animal was born and it’s PAP score. However, there is a significant
difference in PAP between breeds of cattle.
Introduction High
altitude can cause major stresses on cattle unrelated to weather and
terrain. One problem that arises frequently is that of potentially
deadly High Altitude Pulmonary Edema. There have been many studies in
humans regarding High Altitude Pulmonary Edema (HAPE), but relatively
few in cattle. Pulmonary edema in cattle is
commonly referred to as Brisket disease. Environmental stresses such as
a change in altitude can cause one to five per cent of cattle grazing
at high altitude, usually above 7000 feet, to develop Brisket disease
(Taylor, 1995). By studying human pulmonary disorders and the results
of studies done on them, we can hopefully develop a better
understanding of this costly disease in cattle. Comparison
of the animal’s home altitude and the altitude that Brisket disease
occurs is the goal of this study. Pulmonary Arterial Pressure (PAP) can
be used as a guide for determination of HAPE. The correlation between
the animal’s PAP score and their home altitude will hopefully show me
that as the altitude decreases, the PAP score will increase. PAP will
be taken to learn the pressure in the pulmonary artery creating
elevated pressure in the animal’s lungs. There
have been recorded incidences of Brisket disease since the sixteenth
century, during South American expeditions at high altitudes (LeValley,
1978). Brisket disease affects both sexes and all breeds of cattle.
Natural selection is believed to have a major role in the survival rate
of animals at high altitude today (Schimmel, 1981). Incidence of
brisket disease occurs more often in the spring, summer and fall, when
ranchers graze their cattle at higher altitudes (LeValley, 1978). High
altitudes create a decrease in the partial pressure of oxygen, which
can result in pulmonary hypertension (Enns et al, 1992). Low
atmospheric oxygen tension constricts the pulmonary vessels, which
increases the resistance of blood flow through the constricted vessels
(Schimmel, 1981). Pulmonary Edema causes the pulmonary interstitial
spaces or alveoli to develop excessive fluid, 500 to 1000 per cent
higher than the normal (Guyton, 1982). This can cause the heart to have
an increase in pressure that can lead to myocardial infraction (heart
attack). This inability to aerate the blood can result in death if the
animal is not moved to a lower elevation promptly. Brisket
disease is characterized as right heart failure, since the right
ventricle is the only part of the heart that appears to be overworked
(Taylor, 1995). Autopsies have shown bloody foamy fluid in the airways,
with no evidence of left ventricular failure (Bartsch, 1999). The right
ventricle produces elevated blood pressures to force the blood through
the pulmonary system, which can lead to heart failure (Enns et al,
1992). Symptoms of HAPE can include
restlessness, anxiety, rales, shortness of breath, wheezing, cough,
excessive sweating, pale skin and swollen briskets in cattle. Less
common symptoms include nasal flaring, coughing up blood, dark fluid
diarrhea, and death (Schimmel, 1981). As the case develops, a straw
colored fluid may accumulate in the body cavities until the abdomen is
distended and breathing labored (Hull, 1978). The animal may become
recumbent, reluctant to move and if forced to exert any energy,
collapse and die (LeValley, 1978). Determination
of these symptoms before they occur is a complex process, and certainly
not an exact science. The decreased barometric pressure and decreased
density of air must be taken into account when measuring PAP at high
altitude (Cogo, et al, 1997). The barometric pressure at altitudes
lower than 5000 feet does not usually disturb the pulmonary pressure,
as altitudes above 5000 feet do. Cases of Brisket disease have been
reported in every area of Colorado where cattle are grazed at high
altitudes (Schimmel, 1981). Measurement of the
Pulmonary arterial pressure in humans is done with a Swan-Ganz
catheter, which is inserted into the sub-clavian vein, through the
superior vena cava, into the right ventricle and up through the
pulmonic valve into the pulmonary artery, following the blood flow
through the heart (Darovic, 1995). Pressure is taken here and a pulse
contour curve displays the readings, while the catheter is within the
subject. The procedure in cattle varies slightly for this. Cattle
are held in a normal standing position with a halter holding their
heads to the side so that the procedure can be performed. A cardiac
catheter filled with heparinized saline is thread through a
thirteen-gauge two and one half-inch needle in the external jugular,
through the right side of the heart into the pulmonary artery.
Characteristic pressure patterns show the location of the catheter.
Readings come out on a physiological pressure transducer positioned at
the level of the olecron (Schimmel, 1981). Range
of a healthy pulmonary arterial pressure can vary from animal to
animal, but generally any measurement over fifty mm Hg can be
considered life threatening. Some animals can have a measurement of
fifty mm Hg or above and show no clinical signs of Brisket disease. The
cause of this is still unknown, but possibly these animals are stronger
and more fit to handle stresses in their life. Tests
of HAPE in humans of the same age group were made of children born at
the Lausanne University Hospital, in Lausanne, Switzerland. Half of
these people were born healthy and the other half had a history of
perinatal complications within the first thirty-four weeks of life.
These subjects were all taken to a higher altitude together, and fed
the same diets while participating in the test. The tests showed that
the subjects who had complications as children tested higher in their
PAP. (Sartori et al, 1999). It is believed that if a subject had any
lung complication younger in life, it can affect their ability to
undergo stress on their bodies at higher altitude. A retrospective
analysis suggested that an increase in susceptibility to High Altitude
Pulmonary Edema can occur after infectious diseases, predominantly
those located in the upper respiratory tract (Bartsch, 1999). The
Four Corners Bull Test Station is located in Hesperus, Colorado at an
altitude of 7600 feet. They have put bulls from around the country on
this performance test since 1946. The bulls are all approximately the
same age; they are fed the same diet, and weighed on the same days so
the stresses the animals are exposed to are uniform throughout the
tests. This performance test brings bull buyers from all over the
country, in search for outstanding genetics. Since we have knowledge
that genetics and breed have an influence on PAP, many buyers want to
purchase bulls that test low in their PAP scores so they can start or
continue to breed their animals at high altitude. Studies
have shown that it is better to have a gradual increase in altitude
rather than a rapid increase, due to the changes the body will have to
undergo. Researchers have also observed that exercise should be limited
in the first days of being exposed to high altitude, because the oxygen
is much thinner at high altitudes and exercise demands more oxygen,
which can cause hypertension (Bartsch, 1999). The
bulls that came to the Four Corners Bull Test arrived on October 30,
1999. They began their performance test on November 8, 1999, which
allowed the bulls to adjust to their new environment and all to be on
the same diet for long enough to reduce any variability in their
performance. The animals were weighed every twenty-eight days until
March 1, 2000 when they came off test. They were auctioned on April 1,
2000. Ranchers have had to face considerable
economic stresses due to Brisket disease (Schimmel, 1981). Veterinary
costs for the prevention of Brisket disease, excluding costs of
occurrence, ranks in the top five percent in Colorado (Enns et al,
1992). The goal of this study is to provide information to bull owners,
who can possibly predict their animals PAP test results at a high
altitude, based on their home altitude. If we can learn more about how
this disease works, we can hopefully eliminate some of the economic
hardships that ranchers have to face today. Methods and Materials Study Area: Four Corners Bull Test Station Altitude 7600 feet Data analysis dates: October 30, 1999- Bulls arrive November 8, 1999- Bulls weigh on test December 6, 1999- Bulls were weighed January 3, 2000- Bulls were weighed January 31, 2000- Bulls were weighed February 28, 2000- Bulls came off test March 1, 2000- PAP test scores taken April 1, 2000- Bull sale There
are 124 bulls on test from various owners and different altitudes. Each
animal’s home altitude was collected from the U.S. Geological Survey
(Maintainer GNIS Manager 2000). On March 1,
2000 Dr. Tim Holt, DVM, came to Hesperus to take the PAP scores of all
the animals on test. I was there to record data of the animals’
performance and their individual PAP score. Dr. Holt has been taking
PAP scores sine 1980, and has performed over 87,000 PAP tests. Pulmonary
arterial pressure is measured in mm Hg, and taken with a catheter
attached to a physiological pressure transducer positioned at the level
of the heart. Each animal was lead into a head catch shoot and
haltered, allowing the area on the neck to be sanitized. A cardiac
catheter filled with hyparinized saline was threaded through a 13-
gauge, 2-1/2 inch needle into the external jugular, through the right
ventricle into the pulmonary artery just outside the heart.
Characteristic pressure contours display where the catheter is located
and then held in place until an accurate measurement is taken. I
observed Dr. Tim Holt while he performed the tests on each animal. Dr.
Holt allowed me to perform the test on five animals. The test only
takes about one to two minutes from the time the animal is haltered. Data analysis: I
developed a regression analysis of PAP scores related to each animal’s
home altitude. The animal’s PAP score as a function of the animal’s
home altitude was taken. If there is a correlation between the animal’s
PAP score and their home altitude, I would expect to see a PAP score
increase as the altitude decreases. This will allowed me to determine
that PAP is a function of altitude changes among cattle tested at high
altitude. Results During
the test bull number 29-6 developed HAPE. This animal was an Angus,
from Pleasant View, Colorado (alt. 6900 feet). His sire was from
Hobson, Montana (alt. 4078 feet). His breathing was labored, his
brisket was very swollen, and he was unwilling to move. He was sold at
the sale barn for $30, almost a week after symptoms of HAPE became
apparent. This same cooperator had an animal that had a PAP of 115-mm
Hg, an incredibly high number in 1999. On
March 1, 2000 there were a few bulls that high PAP scores, as well as
small scrotal circumference and low sperm counts. Bull number 34-1 had
a PAP of 87-mm HG. This animal was an Angus bull from Ignacio, Colorado
(alt. 6432 feet), and his sire from Cherokee, Oklahoma (alt. 1181
feet). After failing all the other soundness exams, he was sold and
slaughtered. This animal never showed any physical sign of Brisket
disease throughout the test but did not perform as well as the other
animals’ did. The right ventricle of this
bull was cut open to observe if there was evidence of stress to the
right ventricle and the pulmonary artery. The right ventricular tissue
was dark in color and the muscle fibers were weak and without
elasticity. I compared the right ventricle to the left ventricle for a
comparison of ventricular tissue, and found that the left ventricle was
lighter in color and the fibers were firm. This evidence shows that
even though this bull was showing no physical signs of HAPE, the right
ventricle was still being stressed. The pulmonary artery appeared to be
healthy and smooth, free of abrasions (appendix 1 and figure 3). ![]() Figure 1: The PAP score dependent upon the altitude of the birthplace of the bull in 1000 feet. There is no significant value to imply that PAP score increases as home altitude decreases. Hereford slope was –0.0677, Angus –1.320, and Red Angus –1.017 The
ancestry of the animal has no conclusive evidence that parental
altitude affects PAP scores (figure 2). A scatter plot of each breed
shows no significant difference in PAP score dependent upon altitude.
Figure 2: The PAP score dependent upon where the sire
and dam
were from in 1000 feet. The mean was found between the sire and dam’s
altitude, demonstrating how genetics plays a role in the susceptibility
of high PAP scores. There appears to be a weak relationship of PAP
score and ancestry altitude. Hereford slope was 0.0097, Angus –0.0171,
and Red Angus 0.0153. The
breed of the animal appears to affect PAP score (figure 3). A One- Way
Anova test was performed finding a significant difference in PAP score
among different breeds of animals (P-value 5.43E-08). · Hereford PAP was 37.6+/-0.426. · Red Angus PAP was 46.9+/-1.715. · Angus PAP was 45.7+/-2.0
Figure 3: PAP score is significantly
different among breeds. The PAP scores of each breed were averaged, to
find a variance between breeds, using a One-Way Anova test. There is a
significant difference (P-value 5.43E-08) in PAP score dependent on
breed. The sample size of the System 1 and Gelbvieh’s was so small they
were placed into an “other” category, with PAP scores of 38.5 +/-0.748
mm Hg. The Herefords PAP scores were 37.6 +/- 0.426 mm Hg. The Angus
had significantly higher PAP scores of 45.71 +/- 2.0 mm Hg. The Red
Angus showed the highest PAP scores of 46.93 +/-1.715 mm Hg. Discussion Pulmonary
arterial pressure apparently has no correlation with home altitude or
ancestry, but is more significantly tied to breed of cattle. Natural
selection is believed to have a major role in the survival rate of
animals at high altitude today, due to the highly heritable PAP traits
(Schimmel, 1981). The Hereford breed has been
in the West for many years and is naturally adapted better to the
stresses that high altitude can put on the body. On the other hand the
Angus breed, is usually found in the East or Mid-West of the U.S., and
is less adapted to high altitude stresses. The Red Angus breed is most
often found in Texas and California, and is even less adapted to
stresses at high altitude. HAPE is
characterized as right heart failure, since the right ventricle is the
only part of the heart that appears to be overworked (Taylor, 1995).
The right ventricle produces elevated blood pressures to force the
blood though the pulmonary system (Enns, et al, 1992). When
investigating bull #34-1, which had a PAP of 87 mm Hg, we find that he
never gained as well as the other bulls similar in physical size and
breed, but never showed physical signs of HAPE. This bull had no left
ventricular problems, but his right ventricle was weak and discolored,
demonstrating that the right ventricle was under stress for some time.
His low weight gain could be due to the stress his heart was under
during the test. Bull #29-6 showed labored
breathing, restlessness, anxiety, nasal flaring, and a very swollen
brisket, all common signs of a highly developed case of HAPE. When the
animal was isolated from the rest of the bulls he was recumbent to
move, and obviously in pain from the disease that so many animals
develop. The cost of HAPE is in the top five
percent in Colorado for all veterinary costs (Enns, et al, 1992). That
seems to be the reason that the Four Corners Bull Test brings buyers in
search of outstanding genetics. Since there is knowledge that HAPE is
genetic, buyers are in search of low PAP scores to keep the costly
disease out of their herds. Predicting HAPE
is not yet an exact science, and possibly never will be. The fight to
improve the genetics of cattle herds in order to stay in business is a
long battle, but hopefully with more knowledge an easy road to travel.
This study investigated the altitude that cattle are born, ancestry,
and breed to find another link to understanding the disease that
affects cattle at high altitude. Appendix 1: 2000 Four Corners Bull Test chart including animal ID, altitude of birthplace, altitude of ancestry, breed, and PAP score.
*Bull #4-4 died of Red Water Fever, at the beginning of the test. *Bull #29-6 developed HAPE and died before the PAP test scores were taken. Literature Cited Bartsch, Peter, (1999). High Altitude pulmonary edema. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 31 (1), s23-s27. Cogo, A., Legnani D., Allegron L., (1997). Respiratory Function at Different Altitudes. Respiration 64 (6). 416-421. Darvoic, Gloria O’Blouk, (1995). Hemodynamic Monitoring: Invasive and Non-invasive Clinical Application (2nd ed.) W.B. Saunders, Philadelphia, PA. Enns, R. M., Brinks, J. S., Bourdon, R. M., and Field, T. G., (1992). Heritability of Pulmonary Arterial Pressures in Angus Cattle. Proceedings Western Section, American Society of Animal Science, 43. 111-112. Guyton, Arthur C. M.D., (1982). Human Physiology and Mechanisms of Disease (3rd ed.) pp.157-159, 237-244. Philadelphia, PA: W. B. Saunders company. Hull, M. W., Anderson C. K. (1978). Right Ventricular Heart Failure of Montana Cattle. Cornell Vet 68 (2). 199-210. LeValley, Stephen B. (1978). Pulmonary hypertension in Beef Cattle: A Herd Study. Colorado State University, Fort Collins, CO. Maintainer GNIS Manager, (2000). http://mapping.usgs.gov/ww/gnis/gnisform.html. Sartori, Claudio, Allemann, Y., Trueb, L., Delabays, A., Nicod, P., Scherrer, U., (1999). Augmented Vasoreactivity in Adult Life Associated with Perinatal Vascular Insult. Lancet 353, 9171. 2205-2208. Schimmel, Joseph G., (1981). Genetic Aspects of High Mountain Disease in Beef Cattle. Colorado State University, Fort Collins, CO. Taylor, Robert E. (1995). Scientific Farm Animal Production (5th ed.) pp. 331. Upper Saddle River, NJ. Prentice Hall.
All content on grandturk.org is the property of individual writers and photographers. For permission to reproduce material, contact the editor.
|